Scoring Discrepancies

Name: Scoring Discrepancies
Brand: Listermann Brewing Company
Rating: 4.11 (344 reviews)

Listermann Brewing Company

Cincinnati, OH

Tavour Rating

4.11

Style

Imperial Stout

ABV

11.6%

Find and rate beers like this on the Tavour app!

A Note on This Beer

Listermann Brewing knew they struck Dark Beer gold when they joined forces with the Stout masters at Bottle Logic.

But, little did both breweries know that their 11.6% ABV peanut butter and raspberry jelly project would beat out 96 other killer beers to win Gold at the Great American Beer Festival!

Today, you can be one of the lucky few to luxuriate in the show-stopping Scoring Discrepancies. It tastes like creamy peanut butter and chocolate-covered raspberries, sandwiched between slices of chewy Wonder Bread.

You’ve likely never had a chocolate PB&J before — and it’s even less likely you’ve tried one spiked with this much booze! Plus, this is an epic, 4.37 UT-rated collab!

Since this brew is so sought-after, this may be your only shot at the crave-worthy Gold medal peanut butter and jelly Imperial Stout!

Rated 4.37 on Untappd!

Reviews

4.11

344 Ratings

KonMan

3.0

mouthfeel was almost silty. It’s like too much powder of some kind was added.

czamora

4.75

One of the best peanut butter stouts i’ve had

TheGreyCat

3.75

Thin and the flavors were a bit incongruous and didn’t last well for a full beer.

ZappoMan

5.0

This is amazing!! The raspberries on the nose are perfect. Raspberries and peanut butter subtle float in the flavor mix. I really liked this. Can I give it 10 stars?

Raiderbid

5.0

Killer stout with PB&J tones all the way through!!

Yyyy

3.25

Awesome

Yeli4mvp

5.0

Yep!!!

Hoppygrower

4.5

I definitely get peanut butter and jam

JordanSifuentes

5.0

Rich and delicious

dpens13

2.0

Peanuts and Beer just aren’t my thing

joe13855

5.0

Tasted as advertised. A liquid pb and j.

Ericw

4.75

If you crave pb and j in a beer this is the way you want it to taste. Stellar

BrewdlyDiscoverd

5.0

Peanut butter and jelly in a bottle. Amazing taste. Rich chocolate notes. Tamed bourbon burn.

Savage710x

4.0

Amazing stout! And I hate stouts!

Jmar

0.25

Bottle was infected, foamed out half the bottle upon opening and drain poured the rest for my homies

Oscar.mejr

1.0

Infected.

stefgerke

3.75

Rich and full of flavor

DFreeds

5.0

Amazing stuff. Blew me away on this one.

mlagbas

4.5

Improved as it warmed

kenneth634

5.0

Absolutely INCREDIBLE mix of PB and Raspberry

Gabrielflc

4.25

Second time! Good beer

Gabrielflc

4.25

Bottle logic is always a good choice

nick5175

3.0

andrew7009

4.5

A raspberry and peanut butter sandwich dipped in some chocolate.

michael2357

4.0

Deliciousness!!

zak19

5.0

Liquid pb&j stout

naoki1

3.0

insufficient

ryohei2

4.0

Well-made PB&J stout.

alex7388

4.25

Good

Togepi258

5.0

A bit thin, but the flavor profiles was fantastic. Don't be afraid of the fruit adjunct.

Porter_Bridges

2.0

Starts off very sweet and fades to a coffee and raspberry jam. Didn't taste the peanut butter at all.

Jbreed

5.0

Well I can certainly see how this won a gold medal. Like biting into a boozy PB&J!

Gilsmit

4.75

The raspberry flavor in this is perfect. Also a ton of peanut butter. This beer is amazing

EJV4

4.0

Strong berry on the nose that transitioned to peanut butter aroma as it warmed up. Sweet jammy flavor with light carbonation and medium body.

NJgoodbeer

5.0

Perfect balance and hard to believe it’s 11.6%

A.Pint

4.75

This beer is a perfect blend of raspberry and peanut butter. Great mouthfeel. It is a must try.

Cubsfan

4.25

Chocolate raspberry peanut butter truffle

Drumz13

3.75

Delicious. More “jelly” flavor than PB, but I still get both flavors. Great stout.

Lukedutelle

4.75

I still need somebody convince me that nobody melted a PB&J sandwich into my glass.

Bigslick929

4.0

All flavors present

casey717

5.0

Not for everyone! But it sure does check the boxes for what it was trying to be. It's straight up like eating a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. 100% on the mark. Grab a friend and drink slowly as it warms. It's pretty sweet and I don't think I could drink the entire thing.

gaj90027

4.75

PB is overdone but make it interesting with some jam and I'm listening again - thank you! This is a great example of what a flavored stout is supposed to be and Bottle Logic does flavor so well.

goneflyin

4.75

Of the handful of chocolate, deep, rich stouts I received from Tavour, this was one of my favorites so far. Like the best ones, it offers the taste of sweeter things without actually tasting all that sweet. There is the hint of peanut butter, but more on the salty side. The berry comes out on the way down, leaving you with a lingering sense of a PB&J without the sugary, sticky mouth feel. Here you just get that rich and smooth imperial stout flavor with a hefty ABV, yet none of the remnant spiky, boozy feeling that other high-alcohol stouts often leave me with.

Gorim

5.0

The raspberry is done perfectly. Not too sweet. Really enjoyed this

LJBrewing

2.0

Started off pretty good but by the third sip just tasted the typical fake pb flavor I’ve had in other pb beers the berry faded completely away for me.

Tclark

4.25

Read another review that I think says it best, it is like a boozy pb and j.

TrevyWestside

4.75

Bottle logic knows stouts

nicholas2151

4.5

What a F***in stout!!! Like a candy almost. Absolutely delicious! Raspberry, peanut butter and chocolate. Yum.

mario471

4.25

PBJ for sure

christen18

4.75

Very nice